Status as of November 16, 2026. On November 13, the Second Circuit set aside a federal highway funding penalty against New York over commercial driver licenses issued to certain noncitizens. The ruling concerns earlier regulations and does not invalidate newer federal licensing rules effective in March 2026.
A federal appeals court ruled on November 13 that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) could not penalize New York for issuing commercial driver licenses (CDLs) that remained valid beyond the expiration dates printed on applicants' immigration documents. In State of New York v. U.S. Department of Transportation, No. 26-1097, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit granted the state's petition for review and set aside the agency's final determination.
The dispute involved more than $73 million in federal highway funding for fiscal year 2027. FMCSA had found New York substantially noncompliant with federal licensing standards and announced that it would withhold 4% of the state's relevant funds. The court held that the agency was relying on a requirement that did not appear in the regulations governing the conduct under review.
Why federal officials challenged New York
Commercial driver licenses are issued by states under federal minimum standards. The Commercial Motor Vehicle Safety Act authorizes the Department of Transportation to establish those standards under 49 U.S.C. § 31308 and withhold certain highway funds when states fail to comply substantially, under 49 U.S.C. § 31314. FMCSA administers that program.
New York issued non-domiciled CDLs to eligible foreign citizens living in the United States, including some DACA recipients, refugees and people granted asylum. Under the regulations then in force, applicants generally had to present an unexpired employment authorization document (EAD) or a foreign passport with an approved Form I-94. New York normally issued initial licenses for five years and renewed licenses for eight years.
During an audit, FMCSA examined 200 non-domiciled commercial licenses and learner's permits. It found that 101 had expiration dates later than those on the immigration documents presented by the holders. The agency directed New York to stop issuing affected credentials and rescind licenses it considered noncompliant. It subsequently announced the funding penalty.
According to the court, New York had approximately 32,600 holders of non-domiciled commercial licenses or learner's permits as of July 2025, representing about 7% of its active commercial credentials. The court did not determine whether each of those licenses satisfied every applicable legal requirement.
What the Second Circuit decided
Judge Alison Nathan's opinion examined the federal regulations in effect during the period FMCSA reviewed. The relevant provisions, including 49 CFR §§ 383.71 and 383.73, required applicants to present valid immigration documents at the time of a licensing transaction. They did not require a state to match the expiration date of a CDL to the expiration date on an EAD or other immigration document.
FMCSA argued that expiration matching followed from the requirement to verify lawful presence. The court rejected that reading. It explained that an EAD's expiration date concerns work authorization, which does not necessarily determine the duration of lawful presence. Likewise, the expiration date on a foreign passport does not establish how long its holder may lawfully remain in the United States.
The opinion also distinguished checking documents when a person applies for or renews a license from monitoring immigration status continuously while a license remains valid. The earlier regulations required verification at specified stages. The judges found no textual basis for imposing an additional expiration-matching obligation.
Because that alleged requirement was the sole basis for FMCSA's final determination, the court set the determination aside. Judge Schwartz concurred in the judgment but argued that the majority should have stopped after analyzing the regulatory text instead of also discussing regulatory history. The judges agreed on the outcome while differing on the breadth of the reasoning.
New rules adopted in 2026 are a separate matter
The timeline is central to the case. In September 2025, FMCSA issued an interim rule explicitly linking the validity of non-domiciled CDLs to immigration documents. The D.C. Circuit stayed that interim rule. In February 2026, the agency adopted a final rule after a notice-and-comment process, with an effective date of March 16, 2026.
The revised regulations expressly address how long non-domiciled commercial licenses may remain valid. Under amended 49 CFR § 383.73(f)(2)(iv), a covered license generally may not extend beyond the relevant Form I-94 admission date or one year, whichever is sooner. Other provisions address qualifying immigration statuses and documentation.
The Second Circuit did not strike down those newer provisions. Its November 13 judgment concerned the agency's attempt to penalize New York for failing to comply with a requirement that FMCSA claimed had already existed. Litigation over the newer final rule is proceeding separately in the D.C. Circuit. New York's victory does not determine the outcome of that separate case.
What the ruling means for drivers
The judgment removes the specific federal finding of noncompliance against New York and the funding penalty based on it. It does not grant immigration status, work authorization or an individual right to operate a commercial vehicle. A state-issued CDL is distinct from a person's authorization to work or remain in the United States.
Nor does the ruling direct every state to issue or renew non-domiciled licenses under earlier practices. Current federal regulations, state implementation and individual eligibility requirements remain separate questions. The holding is limited to FMCSA's interpretation of the regulations applicable to New York's earlier licensing practices.
The case illustrates the difference between enforcing an existing regulation and adopting a new one. The appeals court recognized that FMCSA could amend its rules through the regulatory process, but concluded that it could not impose a financial penalty based on a requirement that was not in force during the period at issue.
Sources and court documents
The Second Circuit's November 13 opinion, No. 26-1097, is the primary source for the ruling, audit figures and regulatory analysis. The current text of 49 CFR § 383.73 contains the amended licensing requirements. Reuters reported the funding dispute and its consequences.